| 1950 |
Jim Sweeny - Boston Red Sox |
| 1952 |
Billy Harrell - Cleveland Indians, Boston Red Sox; MVP Eastern League 1956. |
| 1955 |
Jim Walsh - Brooklyn Dodgers |
| 1958 |
Joe McCrudden - Brooklyn / L.A. Dodgers |
| 1976 |
Gary Holle - 13th round by Milwaukee Brewers also w/ Texas Rangers, Chicago White Sox, Philadelphia Phillies |
| 1978 |
Dave Smith - 30th round; New York Mets |
| 1982 |
Ken Hayner - signed w/ Utica Blue Sox |
| 1983 |
Jim Howard - 6th round; Baltimore Orioles (Did Not Sign) |
| 1984 |
Jim Howard - 23rd round; Toronto Blue Jays |
| 1984 |
Larry Monaco - 29th round; Toronto Blue Jays |
| 1984 |
Tom Winter - 24th round; Toronto Blue Jays |
| 1989 |
Chris Alesio - signed w/ St. Louis Cardinals |
| 1989 |
Chris Gorton - signed w/ St. Louis Cardinals |
| 1989 |
Dave Howard - 24th round; Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 1989 |
Shaun Sottile - signed w/ Atlanta Braves |
| 1989 |
Joe Mariano - Albany-Colonie Diamond Dogs |
| 1990 |
Pasquale Arace - signed w/ Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 1990 |
Steve Pinto - Catskill Cougars |
| 1991 |
Kevin Carroll - signed w/ New York Mets |
| 1992 |
Mike Serbalik - 32nd round; L.A. Dodgers |
| 1994 |
Dave Perry - signed w/ Ind. Catskill Cougars |
| 1995 |
Fonz Nopalitano - Welland Aquaducks |
| 1996 |
Tim Christman - 11th round; Colorado Rockies |
| 1996 |
Ira Tilton - 5th round; Philadelphia Phillies |
| 1996 |
Paul Wilders - 33rd round; St. Louis Cardinals |
| 1997 |
Dennis Hogan - signed w/ Ind. Allentown Ambassadors |
| 1997 |
Craig Johnson - 20th round; Detroit Tigers |
| 1997 |
Mike Roberts - 21st round; Atlanta Braves |
| 1999 |
Todd Donovan - 8th Round; San Diego Padres |
| 1999 |
Jeremy Giard - signed w/ Ind. Massachusetts Mad Dogs |
| 2000 |
Kevin Brown - signed w/ Ind. Johnstown Johnnies |
| 2000 |
Dave Fields - signed w/ Ind. Chillicothe Paints |
| 2000 |
Nick Spera - signed w/ Ind. Nashua Pride |
| 2002 |
Dave Pahucki - 23rd round; Boston Red Sox |
| 2002 |
Jim Buckley - 25th round; Boston Red Sox |
| 2002 |
Justin Knoff - 30th round; Cincinnati Reds |
| 2002 |
Ryan Finn - Albany-Colonie Diamond Dogs |
| 2002 |
Josh Kean - Albany-Colonie Diamond Dogs |
| 2003 |
Josh Courage; Signed with Pensacola Pelicans, played professionally in France |
| 2004 |
Ryan Bitter - 22nd Round; Tampa Bay Devil Rays |
| 2004 |
Blake Hanan - signed with Baltimore Orioles |
| 2005 |
John Lannan - 11th Round; Washington Nationals (Philadelphia Phillies/New York Mets) |
| 2008 |
Chris Klepps- Signed w/ Ind. Windy City Thunderbolts (Frontier League) |
| 2009 |
Will Hassett - signed w/ Ind. Rockland Boulders (Can-Am League) |
| 2009 |
Anthony Giansanti - 49th Round; Oakland A's (Did Not Sign) |
| 2010 |
Anthony Giansanti - Free Agent; Chicago Cubs (Current team - Sultanes de Monterrey - Mexican League) |
| 2011 |
Dan Paolini - 10th Round; Seattle Mariners |
| 2011 |
Kevin Quaranto - Free Agent; Philadelphia Phillies |
| 2013 |
Mike Fish - 32nd Round; Los Angeles Angels |
| 2014 |
Larry Balkwill - signed w/ Ind. Le Capitales de Quebec (Can-Am League) |
| 2014 |
Justin Brantley - Free Agent; Cleveland Indians |
| 2014 |
Matt Gage - 10th Round; San Francisco Giants (Current team - Reno Aces - AAA, Arizona Diamondbacks) |
| 2015 |
Matt Quintana - Signed w/ Ind. Bridgeport Bluefish (Atlantic League) (Current team - Sioux City Explorers - American Association) |
| 2016 |
Kyano Cummings - Signed w/ Ind. Evansville Otters (Frontier League) |
| 2017 |
Dan Swain - 34th Round; Arizona Diamondbacks |
| 2018 |
Marcos Campos - 29th Round; San Francisco Giants |
| 2018 |
Tom Sutera - Free Agent; Philadelphia Phillies (Current team - JerseyShore BlueClaws - High A, Philadelphia Phillies) |
| 2019 |
Brendan White - 26th Round; Detroit Tigers (Current team - West Michigan Whitecaps - High A, Detroit Tigers) |
